Enhance and expand your sexual experiences. We carry a wide variety of high-quality butt plugs so you can find the size, shape and material that you enjoy the most. For more information read our guide or watch our video and learn which anal toys will be best for you and your partner.

Was:

$46.95
$26.50

The Three Bumps for Your Rump Butt Plug

AB387-small
All Sex Toys Anal Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Ep46 Pegging ExtremeRestraints.com Gifts Under $50 Huge Butt Plugs Huge Dildos Insertables Master Series Safe Best Sellers Self-Love Toys Sex Toys on Sale Top Rated Products Top Sex Toy Brands Trending Now
The Three Bumps for Your Rump Butt Plug gives you triple the pleasure All the benefits of anal beads, in a suction cup butt...

Was:

$33.95
$19.95

Aria Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug

AD330-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Classic Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Ep25 Anal Play Ep46 Pegging Ep54 Female Chastity Ep72 The Travel Show ExtremeRestraints.com Gifts for Women Gifts for Women Product Videos Safe Top Rated Sex Toys on Sale Top Items of 2018 Top Rated Products Trending Now Valentines Day Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs Vogue
From beginners to advanced players, this vibrating butt plug will offer deep stimulation This butt plug is great for those who are curious about...

Was:

$16.95
$9.95

Red Heart Gem Anal Plug

AF633-Small
All Sex Toys Anal Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Ep100 Don't Be Afraid of Sex Toys For Kinky Couples Gifts for Women Gifts for Women Gifts of the Heart Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Patriotic Play Product Videos Sex Toys on Sale Trending Now
Show your partner some love when you bend over! Who knew that the best way to someone's heart is sometimes through the booty? Available...

Was:

$49.95
$29.95

Silicone Tapered Anal Hose

AG513-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Hosed Huge Butt Plugs Huge Dildos Sex Toys on Sale Top Items Between $50 - $100 Top Rated Products Trending Now
How Many Inches Can Your Ass Take?! Push Your Limits! Take deep probing to an evil level! Challenge your butthole with this numbered Tapered...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Pink Gem Anal Plug

AF631-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Gifts Under $10 Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Product Videos Sex Toys on Sale Trending Now
Show your partner exactly what kind of princess they're dealing with! Pretty in pink, the gem in this sparkling anal accessory will demand the...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Clear Gem Anal Plug

AF632-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Gifts for Women Gifts for Women Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Product Videos Safe Best Sellers Sex Toys on Sale Top Items of 2018 Trending Now
Make that booty shine like a diamond! Whatever your partner is expecting to see when you bend over, it's not this! Available in three...

Was:

$22.95
$14.95

Dark Invader Metal and Silicone Anal Plug

AG343-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Ep88 High Tech Anal Play Gifts Under $50 Glass and Steel Dildos Master Series Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands
Take In The Best of Both Worlds With These Metal/Silicone Hybrid Butt Plugs! Wrap your hole around the satisfying weight of this hybrid silicone...

Was:

$28.95
$18.95

Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug

AG472-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Classic Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Gifts Under $50 Heavy Hitters Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Top Rated Products Trending Now Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs
Comfy Fulfilling Anal Plugs Featuring LInternal Weight! These luxurious anal plugs from Heavy Hitters are designed to satisfy your need for anal fill with...

Was:

$52.95
$32.95

The Anal Destroyer Butt Plug

AC581-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs ExtremeRestraints.com Huge Butt Plugs Master Series Sex Toys on Sale Top Rated Products Top Sex Toy Brands Trending Now
Step up to the big time of anal stretching, with the Anal Destroyer Butt Plug When you're ready for the anal stretch of a...

Was:

$62.95
$39.95

Remote Control 21X Vibrating Silicone Swirl Butt Plug

AG564-Black
All Sex Toys Bang Best Sellers Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Lacy Lennon Patriotic Play Pierce Paris Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Remote-Controlled Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
Meaty, Satisfying Swirls Crafted For Backdoor Pleasure Squeeze your ass on the delicious swirls found spiraling on this silicone anal plug! Featuring a tapered...

Was:

$13.95
$9.95

Clear View Hollow Anal Plug

AG732-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Master Series Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands
A Tunnel of Love to Look Deep Inside! Key Features: Transparent Plug: See deep within your lover’s hole with this transparent TPE anal plug!...

Was:

$62.95
$39.95

Remote Control 21X Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug

AG563-Black
All Sex Toys Bang Best Sellers Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Lacy Lennon Patriotic Play Pierce Paris Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Remote-Controlled Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
An Easy Entry Silicone Butt Plug For All Skill Levels! Smooth and tapered for easy entry and a satisfying fill, and packed with a...

Was:

$25.95
$18.95

Premium Silicone Weighted Prostate Plug

AG765-Small
All Sex Toys Aspen Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Butt Plugs Classic Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Gifts for Men Gifts for Men Heavy Hitters Metal Butt Plugs Prostate Massagers Sex Toys on Sale Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs Vibrating Sex Toys
Take a Heavy Hit to Your Backdoor! Internal Weights Feel the downward pull in your backdoor - these unique butt plugs feature two weights...
Sold out
ag329-medium_1000x991 ag329-medium-info-001

Was:

$48.95
$32.95

Squeezable Silicone Anal Plug

AG329-Large
All Sex Toys Butt Plugs Classic Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Ep88 High Tech Anal Play Huge Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Squeeze-It Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs
Stuff this satisfyingly squishy plug up your bum! Choose between the small, medium, or large plug to experience the spade-like shape stretching you wide...

Was:

$18.95
$12.95

PeepHole Clear Hollow Anal Plug

AF816-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Sex Toys on Sale
Get a clear view into your partner's asshole! Available as a small or large plug, these hollow anal accessories allow you to glimpse into...

Was:

$15.95
$9.95

Rainbow Prism Gem Anal Plug

AG375-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale
Add a Rainbow Sparkle to Your Subs Ass! Add a dazzling rainbow shine to the ass of your lover, or insert into your booty...

Was:

$51.95
$33.95

Triple Cones 3 Piece Anal Plug Set

AG457-Black
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Classic Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Master Series Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands
A Dynamic Trio of Anal Plugs For Training and Play Play and train with this set of deliciously rounded anal plugs! Shaped like cones...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Smooth Vibrating Anal Plug

AG294-Black
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Frisky Gifts Under $10 Kira Noir Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
Push this sleek plug up your ass to feel the buzz! Discover the smooth seduction of this comfortably tapered anal accessory. Press the button...

Was:

$46.95
$29.95

Remote Control Vibrating Silicone Anal Beads

AG614-Black
All Sex Toys Bang Beads and Balls Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Lacy Lennon Pierce Paris Product Videos Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
Velvety Silicone Anal Beads For All Enjoy each of these silky beads entering and exiting your backdoor with ease! The tapered tip, flexible body,...

Was:

$20.95
$12.95

Hive Ass Tunnel Silicone Ribbed Hollow Anal Plug

AF982-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Sex Toys on Sale
Massage your fuck tunnel while it's spread open! With 3 sizes to choose from, this unique butt plug provides a one-of-a-kind experience. Choose between...

Was:

$53.95
$33.95

The Abyss Hollow Anal Dilator

AF924-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Glass and Steel Dildos Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Lance Hart Master Series Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands
Even plugged up, that hole will be open for invasion! This metal plug is available in 3 different sizes to give you the perfect...

Was:

$16.95
$9.95

Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug

AG430-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Chrissy Marie Dildos & Insertables Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Glass and Steel Dildos Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale
Add A Glass Dazzle to Your Derriere! Smooth and solid, this glass plug features a dazzling pink gem to give your backdoor a sexy...

Was:

$16.95
$9.95

Lucky Clover Gem Anal Plug

AG185-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Casey Calvert Dildos & Insertables Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale
Get lucky... in your ass! These smooth metal butt plugs are adorned at the base with a beautiful four-leaf-clover design. Surprise your partner when...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Black Rose Anal Plug

AF635-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Product Videos Sex Toys on Sale
Decorate your rosebud with an intriguing accessory. Real roses will wilt, and your lover is guaranteed to appreciate what's nestled between your ass cheeks...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Ribbed Vibrating Butt Plug

AG295-Black
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Frisky Gifts Under $10 Kira Noir Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
Bust each buzzing bubble into your booty! Follow up the tapered first bulb of this rippled rump rocker with two more smooth bulges. Press...

Was:

$25.95
$19.95

Ass Bung Clear Hollow Anal Dilator with Plug

AG756-Med
Alexis Tae All Sex Toys Aspen Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Master Series Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands
A Hollow Hole for Fun and Fucking Key Features: Deep Inner Stretch: Enjoy the deep stretch as the dilator spreads open your ass. Flexible...

Was:

$14.95
$9.95

Red Rose Anal Plug

AF634-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Patriotic Play Product Videos Sex Toys on Sale
Surprise your lover with a single red rose! Embrace the romantic cliche in a sexier and more long-lasting way with this beautiful anal accessory!...

Was:

$20.95
$13.95

Glow-In-The-Dark Glass Anal Plug

AG555-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs
Make Your Booty Glow! These hard, satisfying anal plugs provide a pleasurable fill and a kinky glow to your backdoor! Constructed with smooth and...

Was:

$15.95
$9.95

Rainbow Prism Heart Anal Plug

AG374-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Gifts of the Heart Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale
Wear Your Heart on Your Ass with This Rainbow Metal Butt Plug! This hefty Rainbow Heart butt plug puts your love on display for...

Was:

$51.95
$29.95

Xeno Egg Glow in the Dark Silicone Egg

AH067-Large
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Creature Cocks Dildos & Insertables Insertables Product Videos Self-Love Toys Sex Toys on Sale Top Items Between $50 - $100 Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs
The Orgasmic Gift of the Glowing Egg! Key Features Glow-In-The-Dark Alien Egg: Let your sci-fi fantasies run wild with this glow-in-the-dark alien xeno egg!...

Was:

$24.95
$18.95

The JOCK Duo Anal Plugs

AF817-Black
All Sex Toys All-American Curve Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Classic Butt Plugs Curve Toys Dildos & Insertables Realistic Dildos Sex Toys on Sale
Feeling frisky? Pop the small cock in your ass! Feeling naughty? Go big, baby! These fun little plugs are solid and smooth, with a...

Was:

$15.95
$9.95

Black Heart Gem Anal Plug

AG476-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Gifts of the Heart Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Metal Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale
A Black Heart For Your Derriere Key Features Show Off Your Dark Heart: Fill and prep your ass for anal fun while adding a...

Was:

$78.95
$54.95

28X Vibrating Silicone Pink Gem Anal Plug

AG965-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Remote-Controlled Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Top Items Between $50 - $100 Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
A Beautiful Buzzing Booty! Key Features Powerful Anal Vibes: Cycle through 4 speeds and 7 settings to find the powerful setting of your dreams...

Was:

$28.95
$18.95

The Light Up Anal Plug

AG173-Small
All Sex Toys Anal Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Ep86 Techy Anal Toys Gifts for Women Gifts for Women High Tech Toys Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Product Videos Sex Toys on Sale
Put on a bedroom rave, or actually go to a rave with this trippy butt plug! Choose from 3 sizes to emit a colorful...

Was:

$78.95
$54.95

28X Vibrating Silicone Red Heart Anal Plug

AG966-Small
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Dildos & Insertables Gifts of the Heart Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Remote-Controlled Butt Plugs Sex Toys on Sale Top Items Between $50 - $100 Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
A Beautiful Buzzing Booty! Key Features Powerful Anal Vibes: Cycle through 4 speeds and 7 settings to find the powerful setting of your dreams...

Was:

$69.95
$44.95

7X Light Up Rechargeable Anal Plug

AG253-Small
All Sex Toys Anal Sex Toys Best Sellers Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Chrissy Marie Dildos & Insertables Ep88 High Tech Anal Play High Tech Toys Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Rechargeable Vibrators Remote Control Vibrators Remote Sex Toys Sex Toys on Sale Top Items Between $50 - $100 Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
Put on a light show with your asshole! Take your pick of the small, medium, or large plug to get the party started! The...

Was:

$38.95
$24.95

4 Piece Vibrating Anal Plug Set

AF832-Black
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Dildos & Insertables Sex Toys on Sale Vibrating Anal Toys Vibrating Sex Toys Vibrating, Thrusting & Rimming Butt Plugs
New shapes and sensations for your anal adventures! This kit contains three petite butt plugs and a vibrating bullet so that you can customize...

Was:

$16.95
$9.95

Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug

AG432-Small
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Booty Sparks Butt Plugs Chrissy Marie Dildos & Insertables Gifts of the Heart Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Glass and Steel Dildos Jewel & Decorative Butt Plugs Overstock Sex Toys Sex Toys on Sale
A Heart Shaped Gem For Anal Lovers! Decorate your derriere with a red heart gem to showoff your love for your special someone. Made...

Was:

$29.95
$19.95

Light-Tunnel Light-Up Anal Dilator

AH087-Med
All Sex Toys Best Sellers Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Glass & Clear Butt Plugs Hollow Butt Plugs & Anal Tunnels Master Series Sex Toys on Sale Top Sex Toy Brands Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs
The Light Inside Their Dark Tunnel Key Features TPE Anal Dilator: This firm and flexible toy has enough give to be comfortable inside but...

Was:

$21.95
$14.95

Rump Ringers 3 Piece Silicone Anal Plug Set

RA128-Pink
All Sex Toys Beginner & Anal Training Butt Plugs Best Sellers Butt Plugs Celebrating PRIDE Month Celebrating PRIDE Month - Best Butt Plugs for Men & Women Clearance Curve Toys Dildos & Insertables Sex Toys on Sale
Play safe with this trio of tapered anal plugs! The ringed base prevents these silicone plugs from getting stuck in your backdoor, while the...

Showing: 1 - 40 of 318

Your cart

×