Bizarre Butt Plugs

This is our collection of some of our most unique, popular and inspiring butt plugs. From our popular and unique Anal Intruder Cock Ring to our classic anal plug animal tail favorites like our fox tail butt plug, our selection features high-quality products to make your fetish fantasies come to life. If you just want to dress up extra-special, pucker up with one of our beautiful pieces of anal jewelry such as our flower anal plug.

Was:

$11.95 $9.98

Clear View Hollow Anal Plug

A Tunnel of Love to Look Deep Inside! Key Features: Transparent Plug: See deep within your lover’s hole with this transparent TPE anal plug!...

Was:

$25.95 $18.95

Premium Silicone Weighted Prostate Plug

Take a Heavy Hit to Your Backdoor! Internal Weights Feel the downward pull in your backdoor - these unique butt plugs feature two weights...

Was:

$16.95 $12.95

PeepHole Clear Hollow Anal Plug

Get a clear view into your partner's asshole! Available as a small or large plug, these hollow anal accessories allow you to glimpse into...

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Rainbow Prism Gem Anal Plug

Add a Rainbow Sparkle to Your Subs Ass! Add a dazzling rainbow shine to the ass of your lover, or insert into your booty...

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug

Add A Glass Dazzle to Your Derriere! Smooth and solid, this glass plug features a dazzling pink gem to give your backdoor a sexy...

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Lucky Clover Gem Anal Plug

Get lucky... in your ass! These smooth metal butt plugs are adorned at the base with a beautiful four-leaf-clover design. Surprise your partner when...

Was:

$18.95 $13.95

Glow-In-The-Dark Glass Anal Plug

Make Your Booty Glow! These hard, satisfying anal plugs provide a pleasurable fill and a kinky glow to your backdoor! Constructed with smooth and...

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Rainbow Prism Heart Anal Plug

Wear Your Heart on Your Ass with This Rainbow Metal Butt Plug! This hefty Rainbow Heart butt plug puts your love on display for...

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Black Heart Gem Anal Plug

A Black Heart For Your Derriere Key Features Show Off Your Dark Heart: Fill and prep your ass for anal fun while adding a...

Was:

$24.95 $18.95

The Light Up Anal Plug

Put on a bedroom rave, or actually go to a rave with this trippy butt plug! Choose from 3 sizes to emit a colorful...

ag432-medium-female-model-001a_1000x1201

Was:

$12.95 $9.95

Red Heart Gem Glass Anal Plug

A Heart Shaped Gem For Anal Lovers! Decorate your derriere with a red heart gem to showoff your love for your special someone. Made...

Was:

$22.95 $14.95

Hot Pink Gem Weighted Anal Plug

Decorate your derriere with this dazzling pink gemstone butt plug! Squeeze against the satisfying weight as it displays from your hole, opening a new...

Was:

$19.99 $14.99

The Duke Cock and Ball Ring with Anal Plug

Enjoy stronger, and longer pleasure while your asshole is stuffed with a textured plug! Grand ridges massage the back wall of your anus while...

Was:

$26.95 $19.95

Glitter Gem Anal Plug Set

Add a Glittery Shine Between Your Ass Cheeks! This trio of graduating anal plugs feature dazzling glittery patterns to add a splash of color...

Was:

$128.95 $69.95

The Stainless Steel Anal Hook

The Anal Hook - Get hung up on pleasure! Couples who want to combine the visual and sexual pleasure of rope and anal play...

Was:

$52.95 $29.95

Inception Multi-Functional Sex Sleeve

This sleeve offers multiple uses, all of which result in penetrating pleasure and delight for you and your partner Men, what appears to be...

Was:

$24.95 $14.95

Light Up Silicone Anal Plug

Show Off Your Brilliant Booty! Key Features: Light-Up Buttplug: The base of the buttplug lights up with LEDs and cycles through 3 different patterns....

Was:

$37.95 $29.95

Genuine Amethyst Gemstone Anal Plug

Balance Your Booty with Purple Amethyst! Key Features: Tranquility and Protection: Amethysts are known for promoting tranquility, soothing stress and anxiety and enhancing psychic...

Was:

$34.95 $19.95

Booty Bloom Silicone Rose Anal Plug

Make Your Booty Bloom With This Silicone Rose Surprise your lover with a kinky flower just for them! This rose plug is made with...

Was:

$46.95 $29.95

Pink Gem Glass Anal Plug Set

A Set of Glass Anal Gems For Training and Play! A set of three graduated glass anal plugs for training, warmups, or dedicated anal...

Was:

$81.95 $49.95

Anal Intruder Cockring

AA325

All Sex Toys Anal Sex Toys Best Sellers Bizarre Butt Plugs Butt Plugs Dildos & Anal Plugs Dildos & Insertables Dildos and Anal Plugs Ep13 Milking Show Ep30 Top Toys of 2014 Ep35 FemDom Ep57 BDSM on a Budget Ep7 The Anal Show Ep81 All Things Cock ExtremeRestraints.com Gifts for Men Gifts for Men Glass and Steel Dildos Master Series Metal Butt Plugs Penis and Ball Toys Penis Enhancement Penis Rings Penis Rings With Butt Plugs, Prostate & Taint Stimulators Sex Toys on Sale Show Off Your Cock Staff picks Steel, Chrome & Other Metal Penis Rings Top Rated Products Top Sex Toy Brands Trending Now Tyler Morgan Unique & Special-Purpose Butt Plugs Valentines Day

The Anal Intruder Cock Ring is a unique device that not only keeps your cock stiff, but also keeps your ass stuffed. The stainless...

The Earl Cock and Ball Ring with Anal Plug

Was:

$19.95 $12.95

The Earl Cock and Ball Ring with Anal Plug

Experience erotic ecstasy in your cock, balls, and asshole with this male pleasure tool! Regally curved with smooth bumps to massage your rump, this...

Was:

$76.95 $49.95

Gape-Grommets 3 Piece Hollow Silicone Anal Dilator Set

Anal Openers for Advanced Anal Enthusiasts This 3 piece grommet kit is built for true anal lovers! Designed to stretch open your backdoor for...

Was:

$36.95 $22.95

Pleasure Poker Textured Glove

Using your hand has never felt this good! Take manual pleasure to the next level with a glove that adds new textures to masturbation...

Was:

$41.95 $24.95

The Stuffer Fisting Hand Dildo

Work this hand up into your hole! Ready to take an entire life-sized hand deep in your pussy or asshole? All five fingers of...

Was:

$45.95 $29.95

Emerald Gem Anal Plug Set

Glittering green between your cheeks! Explore all 3 sizes of a beautiful butt plug. This elegant trio of smooth metal butt plugs is adorned...

Was:

$62.95 $44.95

Male Chastity Harness with Silicone Anal Plug

Cage His Cock In Style Key Features: PU Leather Straps: The harness is made of PU leather so it has the classic style of...

Was:

$89.95 $49.95

Cat Tail Anal Plug and Mask Set

Congrats! You've found today's daily deal. Transform into the purrfect pet for your partner! A seductive kitty mask and a flexible tail plug create...